Pre-Mortem: Find What Could Go Wrong Before a Big Decision

Before a big decision, most people picture success. A pre-mortem does the opposite: imagine the plan has failed, then ask why. It is a quick way to find risks early, while you can still change course. Here is how to run one alone or with others.

By Rohan Rawat

What a pre-mortem is

The pre-mortem method was developed by psychologist Gary Klein. The idea is to imagine, before a project starts, that it has already failed, and to write down the reasons why. Because failure is assumed, people feel freer to name worries that they might otherwise keep to themselves. A short description of the method is on Psychology Today.

It is a thinking tool, not a prediction. It will not tell you whether the plan will succeed, but it improves the plan by surfacing what could go wrong.

When to use it

  • Before starting a project, launching something or making a move.
  • Before a decision that is hard to reverse: a career change, a big purchase, a commitment of time or money.
  • When everyone seems very confident, and nobody has asked what could go wrong.

How to run one in 20 minutes

  1. Describe the plan in two or three sentences, with the date it is meant to be complete.
  2. Imagine it has failed. Say it plainly: "It is six months from now, and this has failed badly."
  3. Write down reasons, alone, for five minutes. Aim for as many as you can, from small to serious. If you are in a group, each person writes separately first, so the loudest voice does not set the list.
  4. Share and combine. Go round, one reason each, until all are listed. Group similar ones.
  5. Rate each reason for likelihood and impact, such as high, medium or low.
  6. Act on the top ones. For each, decide a prevention step, an early warning sign and who will watch for it.
  7. Update the plan, and note what you will check at the next review.

Turning worries into actions

Possible reason for failureLikelihoodImpactPrevention or early warning
Key person leaves or becomes unavailableMediumHighDocument the work; name a backup now
Costs rise above what we expectedHighMediumGet written quotes; add a buffer; review monthly
We never agreed what "done" meansMediumHighWrite the outcome in a one-page brief
Example: moving to a new job in another city

Imagine it has gone badly a year later. Reasons: the commute or cost of living was worse than expected; the team culture was not what was described; the partner could not find work; the lease was too long. Actions: visit the city and team before accepting, ask for a written description of the role, check the lease terms and agree a review date at six months with a fallback plan.

Edge cases

  • Decisions with medical, legal or financial consequences. A pre-mortem helps you prepare questions. The answers should come from qualified professionals.
  • Over-worrying. If the list makes you freeze, pick the top three risks and act on them. The goal is better decisions, not endless fear.
  • Teams where people hesitate to speak. Use written, anonymous or separate notes first, and have the leader share their own concerns first.
  • Everything looks risky. Break the plan into smaller steps, or test it in a small way before committing fully.
  • You still want to go ahead. That is fine. You are going in with your eyes open and a plan.

Pre-mortem worksheet

PRE-MORTEM   Plan: ____________________   Date: ________

THE PLAN (2-3 sentences, with end date): ____________________
IT HAS FAILED. WHY? (5 minutes, write alone)
1. ____________________  Likelihood H/M/L ___  Impact H/M/L ___
2. ____________________  Likelihood H/M/L ___  Impact H/M/L ___
3. ____________________  Likelihood H/M/L ___  Impact H/M/L ___
4. ____________________  Likelihood H/M/L ___  Impact H/M/L ___
5. ____________________  Likelihood H/M/L ___  Impact H/M/L ___

TOP RISKS: prevention step / early warning sign / who watches
a) ____________________________________________
b) ____________________________________________
c) ____________________________________________

PLAN CHANGES: ____________________   Review date: ________
Recap

Imagine the plan has failed, write down why, rate the reasons, then turn the top ones into prevention steps and early warning signs. Update the plan and set a review date. Use professionals for medical, legal or financial answers.

Next step

Pick one upcoming decision and spend five minutes writing why it might fail. Then compare your options with the compare two options worksheet.