A Decision Worksheet for Comparing Two Options

You are torn between two options and keep going around in circles. A short worksheet gets the criteria out of your head, shows where the real difference lies and helps you see whether you are close to a decision or just missing one fact.

What this worksheet is, and is not

It is a thinking aid. It makes you name what matters, give it a weight and compare the options on each point. It does not make the decision for you, and a score is only as good as the honesty of your inputs. For big decisions that affect health, money, legal rights or safety, use it to prepare your questions, then speak to a qualified professional.

The seven steps

  1. Write the decision as a question. "Should I take the 8:10 train or drive to work?" A clear question prevents the options from changing halfway through.
  2. Set a deadline. When do you need to decide, and what happens if you do not? Many decisions are easier once you notice that the cost of waiting is small, or large.
  3. List your deal-breakers. These are conditions an option must meet to be acceptable at all. If an option fails one, it is out, whatever its score.
  4. List three to seven criteria. Things that matter, such as cost, time, stress, flexibility or effect on other people. If you are choosing for others, ask what matters to them.
  5. Weight each criterion from 1 to 5. 5 means "this matters a great deal", 1 means "nice to have". Use each number more than once only if you mean it.
  6. Score each option from 1 to 5 on each criterion. 5 means "very good on this point". Score one criterion at a time across both options, not one option at a time.
  7. Multiply, add up and sanity-check. Weight times score for each cell, then total each option. Then ask the checks below.

Four checks after the scores

  • Is it close? If totals are within a few points, the criteria probably do not separate the options. Look for a missing criterion or accept that either choice is fine.
  • Gut check. Which result did you hope for as you scored? That reaction is information. It may point to a criterion you left out.
  • Is it reversible? Easy to undo decisions deserve less deliberation than hard-to-undo ones. If you can try one option and switch, try it.
  • What would change my mind? Write the fact that would flip the result, then decide whether you can find it before your deadline.
Example: train or drive to work
CriterionWeightTrainDrive
Predictable arrival time543
Cost per week332
Can read or rest on the way251
Flexibility to leave late425

Train: 5×4 + 3×3 + 2×5 + 4×2 = 47. Drive: 5×3 + 3×2 + 2×1 + 4×5 = 43. The gap is small, so the real question is how often flexibility matters. A trial of each for a week may settle it better than more scoring.

Edge cases

  • More than two options. Narrow to the best two first by removing any that fail a deal-breaker, then compare the finalists.
  • You are deciding with someone else. Fill in the weights separately, then compare. Differences in weights often explain the disagreement better than differences in scores.
  • Numbers feel false. If you cannot score something, use rough descriptions such as low, medium, high and convert later, or leave the criterion out and mention it in your notes.
  • A criterion that cannot be compared. Values such as "this fits who I want to be" may be best handled as deal-breakers or by a conversation, not a number.
  • Decision fatigue. If you have rerun the worksheet three times with the same result, you have decided. Act on it.

Decision matrix tool

The tool below does the multiplication and totals for you. It works for two options. It runs in your browser, sends nothing anywhere and saves nothing, so copy or print the result before leaving the page. The plain-text worksheet follows for pen and paper.

Two-option decision matrix

Name your options, add criteria, give each a weight and score each option from 1 to 5, then choose "Calculate".

Deal-breakers

Criteria

CriterionWeight (1-5)Score A (1-5)Score B (1-5)Remove row

Plain-text worksheet

DECISION (as a question): ______________________________
DECIDE BY: ____________  IF I DO NOT DECIDE: ____________

DEAL-BREAKERS (an option that fails is out)
- 
- 

CRITERIA       WEIGHT   A: score  A: w x s   B: score  B: w x s
1. __________    __       __        __         __        __
2. __________    __       __        __         __        __
3. __________    __       __        __         __        __
4. __________    __       __        __         __        __
5. __________    __       __        __         __        __
TOTAL                                ____                ____

CHECKS
Close? ____  Gut feeling: ________  Reversible? ____
What would change my mind: ______________________________
DECISION: ___________  FIRST STEP: ________________
Recap

State the decision, set a deadline, list deal-breakers, choose a few weighted criteria, score both options and total them. Then check how close it is, notice your gut reaction, ask whether you can undo the choice, and name what would change your mind.

Next step

Run one real decision through the tool today, then write down the first step of whichever option wins. If the choice is about what to work on first rather than between two options, see What to Do Next When Everything Feels Urgent.