Write Your Self-Review With Evidence: A Simple Worksheet

Review time is stressful when you cannot remember what you did in March. Keep a running log through the year, then use it to write a specific, balanced self-review with evidence. This guide includes a simple worksheet.

By Rohan Rawat

Who this is for

This is for employees, and also for volunteers and students who are asked to reflect on their own progress. Use it at the start of a review period to set up a log, weekly or monthly as you add to it, and in the week before you must submit your self-assessment. Your employer's process and forms always come first; this guide helps you gather the material to fill them in well. It is about showing your work, not about asking for pay, which is a separate conversation.

Keep a running achievements log

Memory favours recent weeks and the dramatic. A log fixes that. Spend five minutes at the end of each week, or each month if that is more realistic, and add a line for anything worth remembering. Record:

  • Date. When it happened.
  • What you did. One plain sentence.
  • Impact. Who or what was better afterwards, in numbers if you truly know them, in words if not.
  • Evidence. A link, file name, email subject or the name of someone who saw it. Evidence helps if the review is ever challenged, and saves you searching later.

Include learning and setbacks as well as wins: a skill you picked up, a mistake you corrected, feedback that changed how you work. Keep the log somewhere private that you control. Do not copy confidential material into it; a reference to where the document lives is enough.

Collect feedback as you go

When someone thanks you, comments on your work or suggests a change, add it to the log with the date and the person's role. Ask for feedback directly when it matters, using a short structure such as the one in give and ask for feedback. Your regular one-to-one meetings are a natural place to check how you are doing and note what was said.

Turn the log into a self-review

  1. Group the entries under your goals, your role's responsibilities or your organisation's values, whichever the review form uses.
  2. Choose the strongest example for each heading, plus one or two supporting ones.
  3. Write each point in three parts: the situation, what you did, and the result.
  4. Add a balanced view. Name one area you want to improve and what you are doing about it.
  5. Finish forward-looking. State what you want to learn or take on next.
Example: one entry, then one review paragraph

Log entry: "12 May. Rewrote the new-supplier form after three suppliers sent the wrong documents. Evidence: form v2 in the shared folder; email from procurement lead. Impact: next 10 suppliers all sent the right documents first time." Review paragraph: "Under 'quality of work', in May I noticed that three of our supplier forms came back incomplete. I rewrote the form with clearer instructions. The next ten suppliers all returned complete documents, and procurement now uses the new version. Next I want to learn to build simple dashboards so we can track this each month." Names and numbers are invented for illustration.

Writing tips

  • Be specific. "Improved the process" says little; "cut the form from three pages to one" shows it.
  • Credit others. Saying who helped makes your claims more believable.
  • Be honest about shortfalls. A fair, measured review is more convincing than an inflated one.
  • Keep it short. A few strong examples beat a long list.

Edge cases

  • A quiet year. Focus on reliability, learning and small improvements, and say what you want to take on next.
  • Work that is hard to measure. Use feedback quotes, examples of problems avoided or the number of people you supported.
  • Starting late. Rebuild the log from your calendar, sent emails and completed tasks, and flag anything you cannot evidence.
  • A difficult year. Describe what happened factually, what you learned and what support would help. Follow your organisation's process if you need to raise wellbeing or workload concerns.
  • Different formats. If the form has set questions or rating scales, answer those first and use the log as supporting evidence.

Worksheet: running log and review prompts

ACHIEVEMENTS LOG   Period: ________ to ________

Date | What I did | Impact | Evidence (link / file / person)
-----|------------|--------|--------------------------------
____ | __________ | ______ | ______________________________
____ | __________ | ______ | ______________________________
____ | __________ | ______ | ______________________________

FEEDBACK RECEIVED (date, who, what)
______________________________________________

SELF-REVIEW PROMPTS
Goal / value: ____________
Best example (situation, action, result): ____________
Supporting example: ____________
What I learned: ____________
What I will improve, and how: ____________
What I want to do next: ____________
Recap

Record dated entries with impact and evidence throughout the period, collect feedback as it arrives, and use the log to write balanced, specific points. Follow your employer's process and finish by looking ahead.

Next step

Create the log today and add three entries from the last month. Then take it to your next one-to-one, using run a useful one-on-one meeting, and schedule your own check-in with the quarterly personal review template. If you want input from colleagues, see give and ask for feedback. You may also find Your First 90 Days in a New Job useful. You may also find Resignation and Handover Plan useful.