Evaluate Online Sources: A Five-Question Credibility Check
A confident tone and a professional look do not make a claim true. Before you rely on, quote or share something you found online, ask five questions about who wrote it, what proves it, when it appeared, who agrees and why it exists.
Who this is for
This is for students writing assignments, for anyone about to share a surprising post with family or colleagues, and for people checking health, money or legal information before acting on it. Use the five questions whenever a claim matters, which usually means whenever it would change what you do, what you submit or what you pass on. It takes two to five minutes once you are used to it. It is a thinking routine and cannot prove that a source is correct, so keep an open mind and be ready to change your view.
Question 1: Who is behind it?
Find the author, organisation or publisher. Look for an "About" page, contact details and a named person. Ask whether they have a reason to know this subject, such as training, direct experience or a record of reporting on it. Be careful with anonymous pages, accounts with no history and sites that hide who owns them. A name alone is not proof; it simply gives you something to check.
Question 2: What is the evidence?
Look for the basis of the claim. Does the page show data, name its sources and link to original documents, or does it just say "everyone knows"? Where possible, move from secondary sources, which describe something, to primary sources, such as the original report, law, dataset or official statement. If a number appears, find out where it came from and what it measures. If you cannot find a basis, treat the claim as unproven.
Question 3: When was it written or updated?
Check the publication or update date. Some topics, such as prices, rules, safety advice and software, go out of date quickly, while others, such as history, change little. Old articles are often shared again as if they were new, so look for a date on the page itself rather than relying on the post that linked to it.
Question 4: Do other reliable sources agree?
Do not stay on the page. Open a new tab and search for the claim, author or organisation, then see what trustworthy independent sources say. This habit is often called lateral reading. If only one site, or a group of sites that all point back to each other, makes the claim, be cautious. If reliable sources disagree, note the disagreement rather than choosing the answer you prefer.
Question 5: Why does it exist?
Every source has a purpose: to inform, to sell, to persuade, to entertain or to attract attention. That does not make it false, but it affects what is emphasised and what is left out. Check for advertising, sponsorship and calls to act or donate. Notice emotionally charged language, such as outrage or fear, and pause before sharing something that makes you feel strongly. Strong feelings are a reason to check, not a reason to hurry.
Extra checks
- Headlines and content. Read beyond the headline, because it may not match the article.
- Images and video. Use a reverse image search to see where a picture first appeared, and look for edits, missing captions or mismatched places and dates.
- Health, legal and money claims. Check with an official body or a qualified professional in your country, since rules differ and your situation may be unique. This guide is general and does not replace professional advice.
- AI-generated text and images. They can sound confident while containing errors or invented references. Verify names, quotes, figures and citations in a reliable source before using them.
A friend shares a post saying a new rule will change how a certain fee is charged from next month. Quick check: (1) the post is from an unnamed account, so there is no one to check; (2) it gives no link to the rule itself; (3) the date shows it is two years old; (4) a search finds the relevant government website, which describes a different change; (5) the page has a banner urging readers to buy a related service. Result: all five questions raise concerns, so the reader does not share it and sends the official page to the friend instead.
Record what you use
If you are writing an assignment or report, note each source as you go, with its author, date, address and the date you read it. A sources and citations log makes this routine. When you take notes from a source, put the claim in your own words and record where it came from, as described in how to take better study notes.
Edge cases
- Reputable source, wrong this time. Even good sources make mistakes. Look for corrections and updates.
- Unknown source, correct information. A source you cannot judge may still be right. Confirm the claim elsewhere before relying on it.
- Personal experience posts. Reviews and stories can help you understand, but they are not proof of how things work for everyone.
- Experts disagree. Say so, and explain the range of views, instead of presenting one as settled.
- Urgent messages asking for money or details. This is a different problem. Use the suspicious message checklist.
Plain-text checklist
SOURCE CHECK Claim: ______________________________ Source/address: ______________________ 1. WHO: author/organisation named? [ ] yes [ ] no Reason to know the topic? [ ] yes [ ] no 2. EVIDENCE: sources, data or documents? [ ] yes [ ] no Original (primary) source found? [ ] yes [ ] no 3. WHEN: date published/updated: ________ Still current? [ ] yes [ ] no 4. OTHERS: 2+ independent reliable sources agree? [ ] yes [ ] no 5. WHY: purpose (inform/sell/persuade/other): ________ Strong emotion or call to act? [ ] yes [ ] no Decision: [ ] use [ ] use with care [ ] do not use/share Official source needed (health/legal/money)? [ ]
Ask who is behind a claim, what the evidence is, when it was written, whether independent sources agree and why it exists. Check images, dates and headlines too, and go to official sources for health, legal and money matters.
Pick one claim you saw this week and run the five questions on it. If it is for study or work, add it to your sources and citations log, and see how to spot a suspicious message for requests that feel urgent. You may also find Share Files Safely useful.