Conflicting Priorities From Two Bosses: What to Do and Say
Two managers each hand you an urgent task, and you cannot finish both. Instead of quietly choosing, show the trade-off, ask the right people to decide and confirm the outcome in writing. This guide gives steps and scripts.
Who this is for and when to use it
This guide is for anyone who reports to more than one person: a team member in a matrix organisation, a specialist who supports several teams, or a new starter with a line manager plus a project lead. Use it on the day you notice that two requests cannot both be done by the dates you were given. The aim is not to win an argument. It is to move the decision to the people who own the priorities, so you are not carrying it alone.
Why quietly choosing goes wrong
When you pick one request and say nothing, the other person finds out late, and usually at the worst moment. You may also pick the wrong one, because you do not see the whole picture. Trying to do both at once tends to produce two late, rushed pieces of work. Saying the conflict out loud, early and calmly, is usually the better option for everyone involved.
Step by step
- List everything on your plate. For each task, write the requester, the effort in hours, the deadline and what happens if it slips. Include the work you already agreed to, not just the new requests.
- Check whether the conflict is real. Can one deadline move by a day, can part of a task be shared, or can someone else help? Sometimes a short question clears it up.
- Prepare two or three options. For example: do A first, then B; do B first, then A; or drop or shrink a third task to make room for both.
- Take it to the right place. If the two requesters can talk, bring them together briefly. If not, go to the manager they have in common, or to your line manager if that is how your organisation works.
- Ask who decides. Say plainly that you want them to choose, and by when, because other work depends on it.
- Confirm in writing. Send a short message with the decision, the new dates and who agreed. Keep it factual.
What to say
Keep the tone neutral and focused on the work. Stay away from comparing the two people or hinting that one is being unreasonable.
- To both requesters: "I have two requests that overlap this week and I cannot finish both by the dates given. Could we spend ten minutes agreeing the order?"
- To a shared manager: "I would like your help prioritising. Here are the two tasks, the effort for each and the options I can see. Which would you prefer, and could you let both requesters know?"
- When someone pushes back: "I understand both are important. I can deliver the first by Wednesday and the second by Friday, or the other way round. I need one of you to choose."
If you are still working out how to decline or delay part of a request, the wording in how to say no at work politely can be adapted here.
Maya is asked by her line manager, Tom, to finish a monthly report (6 hours, due Thursday noon). A project lead, Priya, asks her for a demo script for a client call (5 hours, due Thursday morning). Maya has about 8 usable hours before Thursday noon, so the total of 11 hours does not fit. She offers three options: demo script first, then a shorter report with only the summary page (2 hours); report first and the script on Friday morning; or ask a colleague to draft the report tables. She messages Tom and Priya together. Tom says the summary report is enough for now, and Priya confirms the demo is the priority. Maya replies: "Agreed: demo script by Thursday 10:00, summary report by Thursday 12:00, full report Monday." Everyone has the same plan, in writing.
If your organisation has a matrix structure
In a matrix, you often have a line manager who looks after your development and a project or product lead who directs daily work. Ask early how conflicts are expected to be resolved, for example in your first week. If the answer is unclear, suggest a simple rule such as: project lead sets the order of project work, line manager decides when capacity is the problem. Write the agreement down so it can be pointed to later.
Edge cases
- One of the two is your direct manager. Involve them early, but present it as asking for help to order the work rather than choosing sides.
- Nobody will decide. Offer your recommended option, say you will proceed with it by a stated time unless told otherwise, and send that in writing.
- The requests are genuinely urgent or safety-related. Escalate immediately by phone or the route your organisation uses, not by email alone.
- It keeps happening. Raise the pattern with your manager. A regular weekly priorities check, even for ten minutes, can prevent repeats.
- You feel unable to raise it. Start with the one person you trust most, and describe the workload facts instead of the people.
Plain-text template
PRIORITY CONFLICT NOTE Task A: ____________ Requester: ________ Effort: ____ h Due: ________ Task B: ____________ Requester: ________ Effort: ____ h Due: ________ My available time before the earliest deadline: ____ h Options: 1. ______________________________________ 2. ______________________________________ 3. ______________________________________ Who decides: ____________ Decision needed by: ________ Decision made: ____________________________ New dates: A ________ B ________ Confirmed in writing to: ____________ on ________
List the tasks with effort and deadlines, bring options to the people who own the priorities and ask them to decide. Confirm the result in writing with new dates, and never choose in secret.
Today, write down your current tasks with effort and due dates in the template above, even if there is no conflict yet. When one appears, you will be ready. To sort what is truly pressing first, see what to do next when everything feels urgent, and for the confirmation message, how to write a clear email. You may also find Informational Interview Guide useful.